Trying to resell your preconstruction condo before closing? This blog is for you. Assignment sales are more complicated compared to their resale counterparts, but with some guidance, the process is easy.
An assignment sale is a sale where the original buyers of a condo or home resell their contract to another buyer before closing. The most common type of assignment is a preconstruction condo assignment. Preconstruction condo assignments are prevalent because of the time lag between purchasing the home and the move-in date. While condo assignments might be the most popular type of assignment, any real estate contract is assignable. This blog is going to discuss condo assignments since they are the most prevalent, but *most* of the details apply to assigning a home or commercial preconstruction property as well.
In the GTA, our preconstruction market is booming. Toronto alone sees around 30,000 new home completions a year. Around 70% of preconstruction purchasers are investors. The remaining 30% of buyers are end-users who plan to use the property themselves. However, many investors, and end-users, might decide to sell the property before the final closing. Since there is no title to transfer, these buyers have to assign their contract to the next buyer.
What is a preconstruction condo assignment sale?
An assignment is when the original buyers of a preconstruction condo decide to sell their contract with the builder to another buyer before the home is complete. This differs from a regular real estate transaction because we are not buying or selling a home, rather we are buying or selling an interest in a contract to purchase a home once it’s complete. Essentially, the buyers are taking over the seller’s place in the contract with the builder. The new buyer pays the seller their deposits back, as well as any profit. In trying times, there might not be profit, and in extreme cases, the sellers might walk away from their deposits.
Assignments are like the wild-west equivalent of real estate. The buyers are called assignees, the sellers are called assignors, and there is no fixed closing date! You heard that right, the buyer purchases the contract not knowing whether it will close in 4 weeks, 6 weeks, or 8 weeks. In many cases, the buyers only have a rough estimate for the final closing of the property as well.
Every builder’s agreement of purchase and sale is different, so every assignment sale is different. You need legal and accounting advice before, during, and after an assignment sale. A real estate agent’s job in the transaction is to find a buyer, negotiate the contract, and coordinate the sale from start to finish. Your real estate agent might also connect you with accountants, and lawyers who can help make the necessary legal and tax declarations.
The Builder’s Role In Assignments:
Sellers often misinterpret their rights to assign in their purchase agreements with their builder. In the showroom, builders are quick to say their contract is assignable if you want to flip your contract before closing. However, builders can control when, how, and to whom you sell your contract.
It’s important to follow the rules set out by your builder when marketing your assignment. Deviating from the builder’s purchase contract can result in you losing your deposits!
Since all preconstruction home assignments require the builder’s consent, it’s important to prepare the file for their consent at your earliest convenience. The builder will want the same information they collected from you when you first purchased the home: full names, current address, sin, IDs (front and back), telephone number, emails, mortgage pre-approval letter, lawyer information… they will also want the buyer to replace all your cheques. Those could be cheques for future deposits, or cheques for interim occupancy fees. It’s important to advise the buyers to prepare all of this information before submitting the file to the builder, so there is limited delay assigning the property.
How do you sell an assignment condo?
The first step to selling your assignment is to review your original purchase agreement. The builder’s purchase agreement outlines restrictions and fees associated with assignments. An experienced realtor or lawyer can also review the contract with you. Next, email your builder’s customer service account and ask for permission to advertise the property for sale.
It’s important to thoroughly understand your preconstruction agreement, because some incentives offered to you might not be transferable to the buyer. Builders often offer incentives to direct buyers to stimulate sales. However, they sometimes make these incentives non-transferable. That could mean the free design dollars, or the capped development levies might not be available to the next buyer. It’s important not to advertise incentives that aren’t transferable.
The second step is to hire a Realtor to advise you on current market conditions. Your realtor will discuss marketing options as well as help you decide on a market price. There is a strong chance the builder will prohibit MLS listings of their properties. However, many builders will allow online marketing in places like Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, and brokerage websites.
While Realtor.ca is the best marketing platform out there, buyers looking for assignments know to look elsewhere. Don’t worry if you cannot market on realtor.ca. One of the advantages of Sotheby’s International Realty Canada is our vast marketing platform outside of Realtor.ca
Important Dates:
The first date you need to consider is the assignment closing date. This is the date the assignee officially takes over the contract from the assignor. On average, assignment closing happens within 3-6 weeks after an offer is accepted. This is when the assignee becomes the new owner of the property, and the assignee receives some of their deposit/profit back.
The second date to consider is the interim occupancy date. When buying preconstruction condos, there is usually a period between when the unit is ready for occupancy and before the building has registered with the city. Since no title exists yet, you cannot get a mortgage. Instead, during this time, you move in and pay the builder rent until final closing. Interim occupancy can last from months to years. During interim occupancy, buyers have the chance to view the unit which could help sell the home. Interim occupancy is when most assignment sales take place.
The third date you need to know is the final closing date. This is the date that the building registers with the city and the assignee pays the builder the balance of the purchase price, land transfer taxes, closing costs etc. Sometimes, assignees will negotiate to pay some of the assignors profit on final closing date, so they can roll it into the mortgage.
What Is Negotiable During An Assignment Sale:
Since the contract with the builder is already firm and binding, there can be no changes to that contract. The buyer is merely stepping into the seller’s shoes, in exchange for their deposits and profits. The assignment contract negotiates the purchase price and the deposit structure. The purchase price will indicate how much profit (or loss) the assignor receives in the transaction.
The payment schedule of an assignment is dependent on whether there is a profit or not. If the seller is making a profit or breaking even, then the buyers are expected to refund the full deposit paid-to-date by the sellers. In many cases, that is 20% of the original purchase price. If the seller is losing money on the assignment, then the buyers will bring a deposit for less than the deposits already paid to the seller. The deposit is due upon acceptance of the offer.
If there is profit, the assignee and assignor will negotiate when that profit is paid out. Remember when we mentioned the three important dates? the assignment closing, the interim occupancy date, and the final closing date? well, when it comes to negotiating when to pay the assignor their profit, we usually pick one of these dates to pay out the assignor’s profit.
The expected final closing is an important consideration for buyers when negotiating when to pay the assignor’s profit. The longer the final closing date, the more risk for the buyer. The reason? there is always a small risk the condo developer cancels the project. If a condo developer cancels the project, the buyers are returned their deposits paid-to-date. However, if a buyer has paid an assignor $100,000 in profit, that money is gone. So if there is a long closing, expect buyers to protect their final deposits by delaying it till interim occupancy, or final closing.
Conditions In Assignment Sales
After finding a buyer, the first hurdle to overcome is negotiating a fair deal. Once both parties are satisfied with the terms of the contract, we make the deal conditional on the lawyer’s review. This gives both the buyer and seller a chance to have the assignment contract, as well as the original purchase agreement, reviewed by a lawyer. Once both parties have spoken to their lawyers and are happy to continue, we put the deal to the developer to approve the new buyer. This condition usually lasts around 30 days. If the developer does not approve the new buyer within 30 days, the deal will become null and void, unless the buyer and seller both agree to extend that condition.
Once the developer accepts the buyer, the assignment will happen within a few days. Most contracts outline an assignment closing within 5 business days after the developer gives their consent. Some buyers will also include financing conditions in their assignment offer, so they have time to run the deal past their mortgage broker. However, most assignments are purchased with only lawyer review and developer consent conditions.
Here’s an example of selling an assignment for profit vs selling an assignment for a loss:
Below are four examples of the deposit/profit payment schedule for assignments.
Example 1 is a fantastic example of a preconstruction condo that appreciated $100,000. In this typical example, the assignee and assignor agreed to a deposit big enough to return all of the assignor’s deposits, as well as some extra profit to cover Realtor commissions. This deposit is usually transferred to the listing brokerage within 1 day of the offer being accepted and is released to the assignor on assignment closing. In this example, the assignor and assignee also agreed to pay the seller the rest of their profit at the final closing.
Example 2 shows the same conditions for the sale, except the assignee agreed to pay the assignor their full deposit and all their profit on the assignment closing date, instead of the final closing date.
Example 3 looks at an assignment where the assignor is taking a $100,000 loss. Instead of being paid their whole deposit on assignment closing, they are paid their deposit minus the difference between the purchase price and the sale price.
Example 4 is a rare case, where the market has turned significantly and the assignor is looking to transfer their assignment for $0. This means the assignor is walking away from all their deposits and will take no money to transfer their contract to the assignee.
What Does It Cost To Sell An Assignment condo:
The major fees when selling an assignment include the builder’s assignment fee, real estate commissions, and tax on the profit. Builder’s assignment fees usually range from $1500-$25,000 (in some extreme cases they go as high as $80,000). The assignor usually pays both the assignor and the assignee’s realtor commissions. The commission is something to negotiate with your agent. The total commission is usually 5% or less of the final sale price. There are likely taxes such as income tax, capital gains tax, or HST on the sale as well. Speak to your accountant about taxes due on the assignment sale.
Taxes due on an assignment sale:
The taxes on assignments are simple, however, buyers and sellers often confuse the HST taxes. That’s because there are two different HST taxes when talking about preconstruction assignments. Let’s clarify this! All new homes are subject to HST, however, end-users don’t notice the HST tax because the builder pays it and claims a $24,000 rebate on the end-user’s behalf. Alternatively, investors who purchase a pre-construction home are charged around $24,000 in HST, and are then able to claim a rebate for the HST they paid, if they rent the property out for one year. There are situations where an assignment will lose its eligibility for the HST rebate. If someone has lived in the home during interim occupancy, it will no longer be eligible for the end-user HST rebate.
The second HST tax we discuss when selling an assignment is the HST due on the profit. In many cases, the profit is subject to a 13% HST tax. In some cases, even the return of deposits is subject to HST.
The third tax is the income or capital gains tax on the profit. Any real estate property that is not your primary residence, as well as any business venture, is taxable as either a capital gain or as income. It’s really important to speak to an accountant before selling your assignment. Only an accountant can advise you whether you owe HST, capital taxes, or income taxes on your assignment sale.
Is it better to sell an assignment or wait till the condo is ready?
The pros to assigning a condo:
- Receive your deposits and profit sooner
- Avoid market risks. Savvy investors might look to assign their property if they sense the market might depreciate in the coming months/years.
- Avoid paying closing costs (land transfer taxes, development levies, utility hookups, and more). These usually come to a little more than 5.5% of the purchase price
- No mortgage or financing required
- Minimize holding costs (if you sell before interim occupancy or before final closing, there are no property taxes, maintenance fees, utility fees, insurance, mortgage, etc)
Cons to assigning a condo
- Developer restrictions (limiting the marketing of the property, limiting when they are accepting assignments)
- Market perception and buyer’s hesitancy when buying a property sight-unseen
- Market fluctuations suppressing buyer demand
- Limited buyer pool and most of the buyers are investors who want a good deal
- Usually sell for a lower price than comparable resale properties
- Financing challenges for the buyer if the property does not appraise at the new purchase price
- Potentially more taxes compared to closing and reselling
The most common mistakes when selling an assignment:
Hiring the wrong representation, or not relying on professional advice:
As active realtors in the assignment market, we come across quite a few mistakes. But most of them could be avoided if the buyers and sellers were represented by experienced realtors and lawyers. The agreement of purchase and sale for an assignment is very different compared to an agreement of purchase and sale for a resale home. One of the most common mistakes we see from buyers and sellers is assuming the paperwork their realtors drafted is correct, and forgoeing their right to have their lawyer review the assignment paperwork.
Poor communication/understanding:
This happened to my assignment buyers recently. They purchased a home where the seller’s representative told us the finishes had not been chosen yet. We protected our buyers by including clauses to that degree. However, a few days after the assignment closing, we learned the sellers chose the finishes a few days before closing. Luckily, the developer allowed the buyer to make changes to the finishes at an additional fee.
Ignoring deadlines or dragging your feet:
Assignments come with a lot of moving deadlines, and there are a lot more parties involved compared to a resale property. Always return paperwork and signatures as soon as possible. Compared to a resale property where the only parties are the buyer, seller, and their agents and lawyers, an assignment involves the developer, the developer’s lawyers, the buyer and seller agents, and the buyer and seller lawyers. If everyone took 3 days to return paperwork, the conditional period would lapse and the deal would become null and void.
Incomplete Buyer Vetting:
Buying an assignment requires the assignee to have their mortgage preapproval, as well as their purchase funds available very shortly. If the assignee does not have a mortgage preapproval on hand, it could delay the developer accepting the assignment. If they do not have their funds available it could delay the quick closing as well.
It’s important to thoroughly vet buyers because some builders require the assignor to close in the rare chance the assignee cannot close.
Misunderstanding fees:
Builder’s contracts are not standard forms, and their deposit structures and closing fees can vary from site to site. There are a lot of potential fees when buying and selling assignments and they include, but are not limited to: deposits, seller’s profits, upgrades, lawyer’s fees, interim occupancy rent, utility set-up fees, development levies, realtor commissions, accountant fees, HST, and income taxes. These fees can vary from deal to deal, and when they are payable is different in every assignment. For example, some developers require the homeowner to pay for upgrades when they are chosen, and others charge for the upgrades at final closing.
